By 
Producing employee or student identification cards is a recurring necessity in offices, schools, and security-sensitive environments. The decision to buy an ID card printer or outsource printing services is often framed as a simple cost issue. However, the real cost goes far beyond the upfront purchase or per-card fee. It involves long-term maintenance, flexibility, and control over your PVC card production.
The Upfront Cost
An ID card printer can range from a few hundred to several thousand dollars, depending on features such as dual-sided printing, lamination, and encoding capabilities. That’s a steep investment for organisations that only need a few dozen PVC cards per year. On the other hand, outsourcing eliminates this capital expenditure—you simply pay per card.
However, outsourcing costs add up over time. Those per-card charges, often between $5 and $10 each, including design and delivery, can quickly exceed the cost of owning a printer. The tipping point typically appears within the first year for mid- to large-sized businesses with frequent card replacements or new hires.
Hidden and Ongoing Expenses
Ownership comes with hidden costs often overlooked during purchase decisions. ID card printers require ribbons, cleaning kits, and regular maintenance. Over time, printheads wear out, and replacements can be expensive. Printers in humid climates may require even more frequent cleaning to ensure print quality.
Outsourcing shifts these concerns to the service provider. You won’t deal with machine breakdowns, defective ribbons, or the hassle of storing blank PVC cards. However, you might pay for rush orders or face delivery delays during peak periods, which can disrupt onboarding schedules or event preparations.
Quality and Control
Once you own a printer, you have full control over quality, design updates, and security. You can produce a new PVC card instantly when someone joins, loses a badge, or changes departments. This immediacy is invaluable for schools, hospitals, and security firms that cannot wait days for third-party deliveries.
But that control requires in-house expertise. Poorly calibrated machines can produce inconsistent results, and staff need basic training to handle printing software, ribbons, and alignment. Outsourcing guarantees consistency because professionals handle the process, but it limits flexibility; you can’t make instant corrections or reprints without incurring additional costs.
Data Security Considerations
Internal card printing offers better data control in industries handling sensitive data. Employee photos, personal details, and access codes stay within the organisation, reducing the risk of data leaks. Once outsourcing, even with NDAs in place, you are still trusting an external vendor with confidential information. This instance alone justifies the investment in an in-house ID card printer for some companies.
That said, smaller organisations without stringent security needs may find outsourcing perfectly adequate, especially when working with reputable, ISO-certified printers that adhere to data protection standards.
Scalability and Convenience
Owning an ID card printer offers unmatched convenience for businesses that frequently update designs or print cards in batches. You can print on demand, customise layouts, and adjust for short-term staff or temporary passes without worrying about minimum order quantities.
Outsourcing, while less flexible, is more convenient for one-off projects, events, or when aesthetic perfection matters—for instance, when you need high-quality, glossy PVC cards with complex finishes like UV printing or embossed details that consumer-grade printers cannot produce.
Conclusion
Ultimately, the decision between owning and outsourcing depends on scale, security, and flexibility. Investing in an ID card printer makes sense for organisations with consistent, high-volume printing needs or strict data control requirements. Outsourcing remains practical for smaller firms or those prioritising professional-grade finishes without ongoing maintenance costs.
Whichever route you take, understanding the full picture—from supplies and servicing to security and convenience—ensures that your PVC card printing solution is both cost-effective and operationally sound for your business in the long run.
Visit Paclin Office and let us help you streamline your ID card production today.
Comments